Thinking outside the cookie box

Girl Scout Cookies

Everyone knows Girl Scout Cookies are good. That’s not the problem.

The problem is that most people experience the Cookie Program as a transaction. You pick a flavor, hand over money, and leave. But if you actually stand there for a minute and watch what’s happening, it’s not about cookies at all. It’s a kid learning how to approach a stranger. Make the ask. Handle rejection. Try again. The buyer isn’t really buying cookies either. They’re navigating a social moment and deciding what kind of person they want to be.

When ABC Bakers (one of two Girl Scout cookie bakeries) came to us, the brand was reinforcing the wrong thing. It was polished, product-focused, and easy to consume. It made it easier to buy cookies, and easier to ignore everything else.

So this wasn’t about making things look better. It was about changing what people pay attention to.

Services: Rebrand, Logo Redesign, Brand Book, Social, Content Production, Copy & Design

Scouting out a cookie rebrand

I led the brand and design strategy grounded in a simple shift: cookies are just the excuse. That insight didn’t come from a brief. It came from standing in a parking lot and actually watching the interaction play out. Once you see it, you can’t unsee it. And once we aligned around it, everything changed. We moved away from product-first messaging and toward the moment of the ask. The interaction. The slightly awkward, very human exchange that’s actually doing the work. Photography shifted from perfect product shots to real moments. Real kids. Real interactions. Messaging focused less on flavors and more on what’s happening around the sale—confidence, effort, progress.

We also made a deliberate call not to over-polish it. The system had been trending toward safe and “brand correct,” but that stripped out the thing that made it real. So we created space for individuality and ownership instead. Less control, more truth. Because this program isn’t about consistency. It’s about growth.

The result is a brand that feels more like what the Cookie Program actually is. Not just something you buy, but something you participate in. ABC Bakers saw increased engagement and sales across their product line. But the bigger shift was perceptual. The cookies stopped being the point. They became what they always were—the mechanism for something much more important.

Creative Direction: Stefanie Lutz; Design: Christine Mitchell, Karolina Bassi, Ben Stern; Copy: Matt Siegel

Brand Manifesto

We believe in making. In making things better, tastier, and more accessible than before. We aren’t just bakers. We are crafters and forecasters. Producers and managers. Schedulers and thought-starters. We believe that cookies can drive change and possibility. We are more than cookie sales outside of grocery stores and inside office break rooms. We are continually pushing forward, never quitting, but always questioning how to make things better, faster, and easier for our partners. We believe that giving girls new experiences is what drives the future. ​

And cookies are the currency to get there. ​